AGL vs EnergyAustralia: Which Electricity Provider is Cheaper in 2025?

When it comes to choosing an electricity provider, the decision often boils down to cost, reliability, and perks. Two of the biggest players in the Australian energy market—AGL and EnergyAustralia—are often compared for their competitive rates and offerings. But which provider offers better value for your household? 

If you’re scratching your head over which to choose, we’ve got you. Below, we’ll break down the key differences between AGL and EnergyAustralia in various states, their plans, and how costs stack up. Econnex compares a range of energy providers but may not include all available market offers. 

A Quick Overview of AGL and EnergyAustralia 

AGL has long been a household name in Australia, known for its wide range of energy plans and additional services, such as its renewable energy options. On the other hand, EnergyAustralia has risen as a strong competitor, offering innovative plans and flexible options to meet changing consumer demands. Both companies operate in New South Wales, Victoria, Queensland, and South Australia, serving millions of electricity customers. 

While both providers deliver electricity through similar infrastructure, they differ in pricing models, discounts, and unique benefits like bonus partnerships or subscription bundles. 

Comparing Costs Across States 

Electricity prices can vary significantly depending on where you live, regulated reference prices, and the provider’s ability to offer discounts. Below, we’ll look at the cost comparisons between AGL and EnergyAustralia in key states. 

New South Wales (NSW) 

Based on estimated pricing for Ausgrid network in Sydney, EnergyAustralia offers competitive plan compared to AGL. However, individual costs may vary. 

EnergyAustralia's plans feature competitive discounts, making it a more affordable choice for residents in Sydney. For example, their Flexi Plan offers variable rates with guaranteed discounts on usage. 

Victoria (VIC) 

Costs in the Melbourne area, based on the Citipower network, reveal a tie between AGL and EnergyAustralia, making both providers equally viable. 

AGL’s Netflix Plan is particularly enticing, offering subscribers an annual value of $96 in Netflix perks, making it an excellent choice for streaming enthusiasts. 

Queensland (QLD) 

AGL edges out EnergyAustralia in South East Queensland based on price comparisons in the Energex network. 

EnergyAustralia offers competitive rates, while AGL's current pricing in Queensland may be more cost-effective, depending on the plan and individual usage. 

South Australia (SA) 

When we look at the SA Power network, pricing is neck and neck. Both AGL and EnergyAustralia offer plans that are around 9% below the AER reference price. 

For South Australians, choosing between these two largely depends on the perks offered by each provider. 

Disclaimer: Prices shown for each state are based on estimates as of 10th March 2025 for residential customers on a tariff type dependent on the network type. Actual costs may vary based on location, usage, and provider terms. Prices are subject to change, and for the most up-to-date rates, please check the provider’s website. (Updated as of 10th March 2025). 

Key Plan Features & Perks 

Beyond price, factors like discounts, bonuses, and special features can help sway your decision. Here’s a closer look: 

AGL Key Features 

• Netflix Subscription Perks: The "Netflix Plan" includes $96 of Netflix value each year and petrol discounts at bp. 
• Senior Savers Plan: Special offers exclusively for seniors, with variable rates. 
• Flexible Plans: All AGL’s plans come with no lock-in contracts or exit fees. 

EnergyAustralia Key Features 

• Flexi Plan with Discounts: Offers guaranteed discounts off both supply and usage charges. 
• Rate Fix Plan: Fixed rates for 12 months, providing price stability. 
• No Exit Fees: All plans are contract-free, giving customers the flexibility to switch when needed. 

How to Decide Between AGL and EnergyAustralia 

Choosing the best electricity provider involves weighing costs against benefits to see what aligns best with your household’s needs. Here’s how to decide: 

1. Price: Use the rates outlined above as a guide, but keep in mind that prices and availability may vary depending on your postcode or energy usage. 
2. Perks: Do you value extras like Netflix or petrol discounts (AGL), or are you after simple, no-fuss savings (EnergyAustralia)? 
3. Energy Usage: Compare how each provider’s plans align with your estimated kWh usage. 

It’s also important to compare plans outside of AGL and EnergyAustralia. Smaller, emerging providers may offer better deals, even topping the competitive rates of these giants. 

Simplify Your Search with Econnex 

Feeling overwhelmed? Econnex can help simplify your energy provider search. This comparison tool allows you to easily compare electricity plans from our top providers available in your area, including AGL and EnergyAustralia. Plus, switching plans is seamless and stress-free. 

Take control of your electricity costs today by exploring all your options with Econnex. Start comparing now and find the suitable deal for your household. 

Disclaimer: The plans displayed may not include all available options in the market.